Comentarii la: MSC’s Yacht Club este încă mai bun decât retragerea celebrității? (Comparație de clase de margine)

De: @randijaffe-7665

@randijaffe-7665 — Wed, 09 Jul 2025 14:22:24 +0000

Celebrity suites are much more expensive than MSC, so the cabins can’t truly be compared
Celebrity- lack of shade on retreat

De: @jacksdrums1

@jacksdrums1 — Tue, 08 Jul 2025 18:22:42 +0000

I stayed in MSC YC Deluxe Balcony Suite on Seascape the shower is great, size water pressure was perfect even has a seat , the Celebrity Bath tub is not for me , I don't take baths and showering in a bath tub is not for me. You are correct MSC WIFI was great, I had to work so that is important, Maria is GREAT , I think I told you in another post that I sang to her "Maria " from West Side Story and after that I was Teachers Pet.

De: @JayCanell

@JayCanell — Sun, 06 Jul 2025 00:15:13 +0000

Luminae is closed port days for lunch. YC Restaurant is open. Great option for those that stay on the ship.

De: @seawatchmakers

@seawatchmakers — Sat, 05 Jul 2025 13:53:51 +0000

I booked a cruise on Celebrity in the retreat and they promised a butler will take you to your suite. From the videos I have seen on YouTube MSC groups you togeather then once on board you are separated and escorted to the yacht club where you wait for your room to be ready. At least on Celebrity you get to drop off your bags even if your room is not ready. I'm not sold on MSC yet. I think the big draw to MSC is the price they are cheaper, but for how long. Look at Carnival they use to be the cheapest now they are not. MSC is a shipping company but with the upcoming tariffs there will be less shipping which will hurt MSC shipping company and it will reflect on there cruise ships quality.

De: @NetworkPIMP

@NetworkPIMP — Tue, 01 Jul 2025 18:04:39 +0000

everything is so subjective that no one's opinion matters … folks getting their dopamine hit fighting it out in the comments are usually the ones who couldn't really afford either in the first place and will be making their klarna payments for the next decade …

De: @Bullfeathers

@Bullfeathers — Mon, 30 Jun 2025 19:31:58 +0000

We have sailed on board different MSC ships five times and are booked for an upcoming cruise for New Year’s. Our wait staff in the Yacht Club dining room was always the same each evening. Always found a great food experience and have even the Chef visit with us and asked if there was anything special we wished to have. The ships are gorgeous and you cannot beat the value for the cost.

De: @karmamule

@karmamule — Thu, 26 Jun 2025 16:50:34 +0000

We've been on 4 MSC cruises and on Celebrity Apex once. Both are fantastic, with MSC having larger/flashier ships available and Celebrity being more relaxed and refined. The Celebrity Apex experience was wonderful. Their specialty restaurants were all better than MSC equivalents, though MSC's were fine. We did think the MSC YC areas were better than Celebrity's Retreat area. We were in an Edge Villa on the Apex and it was great, but our upcoming stay on the World America in an equivalent room (Duplex Suite w/whirlpool) literally costs about half of what the Edge Villa did. Overall we didn't think the Retreat was worth the extra money so we'll most likely stick with MSC in the future.

De: @jonathansmith8862

@jonathansmith8862 — Thu, 26 Jun 2025 11:54:30 +0000

I have been a Celebrity cruiser for 20 years in the Penthouse and other suites, I am just back from an MSC Yacht Club Royal Suite cruise and I can tell you hands down MSC have a better service by a mile. The Retreat on Celebrity is nowhere near Yacht Club for the space given and the facilities within it, Yacht Club is a true 'ship within a ship' where you never need to the leave, the area, the restaurant has a huge selection of really fine foods, far superior to the limited Luminae menu, also the restaurant serves breakfast lunch and dinner and not just on sea days for lunch. There is also a full selection of food all day both outside and in the Top Sail lounge. There is live music every night in the Top Sail lounge, the Retreat lounge by comparison is more like an airport waiting lounge. Finally no matter what level of suite you choose in Yacht Club you are met and escorted to the lounge and then to your suite, value for money is great, MSC also matched my Elite Plus status to MSC Gold, so there were more savings, sorry but I won't be back on Celebrity as the Retreat offering is just not enough for the money they are charging.

De: @brunkerj

@brunkerj — Wed, 25 Jun 2025 00:53:23 +0000

You seemed to enjoy having a butler show you to your room. We love our butlers, but I’d rather not have them lead us to our room. Just us, I guess. I enjoyed Celebrity’s Lounge, then went on board first, ahead of other passengers. Once onboard, I immediately dropped my bags in my suite and enjoyed a Luminae lunch. That is part of the embarkation.

De: @michaelgore115

@michaelgore115 — Thu, 19 Jun 2025 13:37:06 +0000

something you STILL NOT address is that the yacht club is quite DIFFERENT on different class ships !!!! the BIGEST world class ships Yacht club is now TOO BIG and suites are also "outside" of the yacht club area – long walks – the food is also INCONSISTANT !!!! MSC EXPLORA JOURNEY is the way to go if you want luxe peace and quiet !